Cambridge Analytica and Tribe Marketing, is this the end of top-tier influencers?

Apr 11, 2018

With Facebook under fire for its recent data manipulations at the hand of the company Cambridge Analytica, the question has arisen as to how such a huge influence could happen?

Cambridge Analytica built up such a massive database of different demographics that it had the power to influence elections, with the most dramatic effects being felt during the election of Trump. These events came about through the ability for a company to separate people into “Tribes”, which single-handedly trumped (pardon the pun) the power of all celebrity influencers who stood up for Hillary Clinton during that election.

The widespread adoption of tribe marketing as a means of building micro-demographics with extremely precise targeting has called into question the value of influencers. Do you really need celebrities backing you when you can just target very small demographics?

I’ll put in my two cents below.

What is a tribe?

A tribe is simply a collection of demographics that are used to form a micro-demographic. Traditional marketing used demographics based on the demographics of age, post-code, socio-economic background and so on. Tribe marketing throws this view out the window, in favour of other, previously unmeasurable data points.

The two most important of these was who you were friends with, and what you liked and followed on Facebook. This information was easily accessible by Cambridge Analytica. With these two sets of data, tribes can be formed. Tribes become the new measure of “who you know and what you know”. Through this information, advertisements can be targeted to small groups of individuals who are no bigger than 250 people, which when compared to traditional demographic sizes in the thousands or millions

Top-tier influencers don’t actually influence; they just broadcast

Somewhat ironically, companies like Cambridge Analytica can use the name “influencer” a whole lot better than what we currently refer to as “influencers”. Tribe marketing is (at this point in time) the one true influencer, where individuals are swayed to a cause one by one, based almost entirely on their tribe.

There is a reason why people don’t follow the voting preferences of the Kardashians, or why Jay-Z’s tidal failed to take off, or why companies that are almost entirely faceless on social media can have a huge following. We hear them, but that doesn’t mean we listen to them. To us they are just broadcasters, no different to watching a television advertisement. There is definitely a conversion rate in there, but it isn’t scalable to the heights that tribe marketing can reach.

It’s the difference between hearing and listening

Tribe marketing is about finding a tailored message that people will actually listen to. Most people don’t listen to influencers that much, unless there is a high level of engagement in the influencer campaign.

Tribe marketing might be the most effective way to go about marketing products, and in time could leave top-tier influencers out in the cold. When we start seeing media advertisements for x number of tribes, we will know the tide has turned.

Online courses for upskilling
By Pamela Distapan 08 May, 2024
Discover the importance of upskilling in today's job market. Learn how free courses can enhance your CV and advance your career. Read more on S2M.
Employee wellness programs
By Pamela Distapan 17 Apr, 2024
Discover how prioritising mental health support in the workplace can attract and retain top talent. Learn actionable ways to enhance employee wellness and create a healthier work environment.
Two women having a conversation at work
By Pamela Distapan 02 Apr, 2024
Discover the latest trends in performance reviews and how HR and recruitment professionals are spearheading innovative changes in the workplace. From continuous feedback to skill-based assessments, explore new approaches to evaluating and improving employee performance.
More Posts
Share by: